Table of Contents
Classic British Puddings Served the Toby Way
For many British diners, a roast dinner without a hot, comforting pudding is only half a meal. The Toby Pudding Co. is celebrated for traditional sponge cakes, crumbles, and towering ice cream sundaes.
1. Complete Pudding Menu & Standard Prices
- Classic Sticky Toffee Pudding (£4.99 - 718 kcal): Dark date sponge soaked in butterscotch toffee sauce.
- Double Chocolate Fudge Cake (£4.99 - 580 kcal): Warm layered chocolate fudge sponge with vanilla ice cream.
- Bramley Apple Pie (£4.79 - 445 kcal): Flaky pastry filled with tart Bramley apples.
- Baked Vanilla Cheesecake (£4.99 - 757 kcal): New York style vanilla bean cheesecake on biscuit base.
- Chocolate Brownie Sundae (£5.29 - 541 kcal): Brownie chunks, ice cream, fudge sauce, and whipped cream.
- Honeycomb Dream Sundae (£5.29 - 391 kcal): Ice cream with golden honeycomb crunch and toffee drizzle.
- Raspberry Arctic Roll (£4.79 - 417 kcal): Retro vanilla ice cream and raspberry jam sponge.
- Cornish Dairy Ice Cream Bowl (£3.49 - 180 kcal): Three scoops of strawberry, chocolate, or vanilla.
2. Custard, Cream, or Ice Cream?
Every hot pudding at Toby Carvery can be tailored with your choice of accompaniment:
- Piping-Hot Vanilla Custard: Served in a ceramic jug to pour over your pudding.
- Pouring Double Cream: Rich and velvety.
- Cornish Dairy Vanilla Ice Cream: Cool and refreshing against hot sponge.
- Soya Vegan Custard: Available on request for plant-based diners.
Written by Sarah Thornton
Specialising in UK dining economics, regional pub chains, and restaurant menu analysis. Based in England and conducting regular audits of Toby Carvery branches across Great Britain.
Last updated on 2026-11-03 • tobycarverymenus.uk editorial team
Got Questions?
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes, Toby Carvery provides takeaway boxes on request so you can enjoy your dessert at home.
